Dr. Nagourney's Blog

With an EVA-PCD Assay, It Can Be That Simple - End Stage CLL Success

By Robert A. Nagourney, MD

Shortly after I left the university and joined a medical oncology group, one of the junior members of the practice asked if I would cover for him during his summer vacation.

Among the patients he signed over to me was a gentleman in his 60s with what he described as “end-stage” chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL).  CLL cells are pictured above.

As the patient had already received the standard therapies, second line regimens and experimental drugs available at the time, the physician had run out of options.

My charge was to keep him comfortable.

I asked if it would be all right for me to study his cells in my lab and the doctor agreed.

I met the patient the next day. He was a very pleasant tall, slender black man lying in bed. He had lost a great deal of weight making the already enlarged lymph nodes in his neck appear that much more prominent.

As I was engaged in the study of CLL as my principal tumor model, I asked if I might examine his circulating CLL cells as part of our IRB-approved protocol. He graciously obliged and I obtained a few ccs of blood.

We were deeply ensconced in tumor biology analyses and his cells were used to explore membrane potentials, DNA degradation and glutathione metabolism as correlates with drug response profiles by EVA-PCD analysis.  A large number of those studies have since been published. 

His Functional Profiling Results Obtained From the EVA-PCD Assay

What struck me about the patient’s EVA-PCD profile was the exquisite sensitivity to corticosteroids.

Corticosteroids in the form of prednisone, Medrol, Solu-Medrol and Decadron are the mainstays of therapy for lymphoid malignancies like CLL.

Everyone receives them.

Indeed this patient had received them repeatedly including his first line chlorambucil plus prednisone, his second-line CHOP and his third line ESHAP.

It was only after he had failed all of these increasingly intensive regimens that he finally moved on to an experimental agent, homoharringtonine, a drug that finally received FDA approval in 2012, after almost 40 years of clinical development.

Unfortunately for him homoharringtonine did not work and it seemed we were well beyond conventional therapies, or were we?

One Last Try At Treatment

I pondered the corticosteroid sensitivity finding and decided to start the patient on oral prednisone. It would be another two weeks before his physician returned and there really weren’t many options.

The patient responded overnight.

The lymph nodes melted away. The spleen diminished.

He began to eat and gained weight. Within a few days he felt well enough to go home.

I discharged the patient and remember writing his prednisone prescription, 40 mg by mouth each morning.

A week later, my colleague returned from his retreat in the Adirondacks. He inquired about his patients and surmised that this gentleman, no longer in the hospital, had died.

I explained that he had been discharged.

“Discharged . . . how?” he asked. I described the findings of our EVA-PCD study, the sensitivity to steroids and the patient’s miraculous clinical response to this, the simplest of all possible treatments.

The physician then turned to me and said “Prednisone . . . hmmm . . . I could have done that.”

Lessons Learned

I am reminded of this story almost daily.

It is emblematic of our work and of those who choose not to use it.

Good outcomes in cancer do not occur by chance.

They also do not require blockbuster new drugs or brilliant doctors. They require individualized attention to the needs of each patient.

A recurring theme, exemplified by this end stage CLL patient among others, is that cancer cells can only defend themselves in a limited number of ways.

Once a selection pressure, in a Darwinian sense, is removed (e.g. corticosteroids were not used during the homoharringtonine treatments) the surviving cells, sensitive to steroids, re-emerge to be identified and captured in our laboratory platform.

It is remarkable how often heavily pretreated patients with ovarian cancer are found sensitive to Taxol after they had received it years earlier, but not since; or breast cancer patients who fail every new agent only to prove responsive to CMF, the earliest of all of the breast cancer drug combinations developed in the 1970s.

Our job as oncologists is to find those chinks in armor of cancer cells and exploit them.

Our EVA-PCD platform, in the eyes of some, may not be groundbreaking . . . it just happens to work! 

 

Dr. Robert Nagourney, has been internationally recognized as a pioneer in cancer research and personalized cancer treatment for over 20 years.  He is a TEDX SPEAKER, author of the book OUTLIVING CANCER, a practicing oncologist and triple board certified in Internal Medicine, Medical Oncology and Hematology helping cancer patients from around the world at his Nagourney Cancer Institute in Long Beach, California.  For more info go to NAGOURNEYCANCERINSTITUTE.COM